Episode 126
Will AI Agents Replace Your CRM?
Bryan Gauch, Leader of BCG’s Commercial Tech Topic, explains why CRM isn’t disappearing even as agentic AI reshapes how customers are served. He argues that CRM will keep serving as the data backbone while agents take over the interface. He also lays out the cost and resourcing questions CEOs need to answer before scaling their AI investment.
You’ll Learn:
Why agents are quietly replacing the screen, not the system, behind every customer interaction.
Why cost is the real constraint on agentic AI, not the technology itself.
How CEOs should align cost, resources, and innovation before deciding what CRM keeps and what agents take over.
Learn More
BCG and Salesforce: https://on.bcg.com/4zTgNKl
BCG’s Latest Thinking on Marketing and Sales: https://on.bcg.com/4zVIMsP
Chapters
(0:00) What Does CRM Actually Do?
(1:29) What CRM Means for Customers
(2:02) Could AI Agents Replace CRM Entirely?
(6:44) The Real Cost of Agents
(8:52) ROI of AI Agents
(10:45) How Will Agents Impact Employees?
(12:55) Where CRM Is Headed in 3 Years
(14:33) How Should CEOs Approach CRM?
(15:53) What Role Will Consultants Play?
Meet the Expert
Bryan Gauch, BCG Managing Director & Partner: https://on.bcg.com/4iI7fLV
Listen to Other Episodes of The So What from BCG podcast
YouTube | https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLMJgyXjV5gMI9JV-GcF_D1Y6zyf1Eab_0&si=plXqe7-YNzbG56U8
Apple | https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-so-what-from-bcg/id1591194141
Spotify | https://open.spotify.com/show/2NSVR7qrAyZ4CaGsnknbBk?si=1d846c2af8784923
Other platforms | https://lnk.to/so-what-general-show12
Follow BCG
LinkedIn | https://www.linkedin.com/company/boston-consulting-group
This podcast uses the following third-party services for analysis:
Podtrac - https://analytics.podtrac.com/privacy-policy-gdrp
Transcript
- Agents are about to do to CRM
Speaker:what CRM did to the Rolodex.
Speaker:- Welcome to "The So What from BCG,"
Speaker:the podcast that explores the
big ideas shaping business,
Speaker:the economy, and society.
Speaker:I'm Georgie Frost.
Speaker:For years, CRM has
been the backbone
Speaker:of how businesses manage
customer relationships.
Speaker:But with agentic AI, is CRM
about to become obsolete
Speaker:or more important than ever?
Speaker:And who will be in charge of it?
Speaker:Joining me today is Bryan Gauch,
Speaker:who leads commercial
tech topic at BCG.
Speaker:Bryan, welcome.
Speaker:The term CRM, I imagine, is
Speaker:quite a familiar one to most of us,
Speaker:but just explain what exactly it is
Speaker:and how significant it is to business.
Speaker:- Well, let's start with
the business definition,
Speaker:as the acronym and definition
have become so overloaded
Speaker:that people forget what it's
actually supposed to do
Speaker:and what it means for a business.
Speaker:CRM or customer relationship management is
Speaker:the strategy and set of practices
Speaker:for managing, hopefully coherently,
Speaker:a company's relationships and interactions
Speaker:with customers across the
entire customer life cycle
Speaker:and to do so in order
to maximize value.
Speaker:Whether you're in One Cards
Speaker:and you're writing
things down in a Rolodex,
Speaker:or you're into technology,
Speaker:that customer information
is that backbone.
Speaker:And I think that evolution is
Speaker:where organizations
have fundamentally gone
Speaker:from "I need to use
this as a business"
Speaker:to IT and tech teams
need to actually manage
Speaker:and harness it from a
security lens to help,
Speaker:help drive secure discussions
with your customers.
Speaker:- What about from my perspective,
Speaker:my perspective being
a customer perspective?
Speaker:What does it look like to me?
Speaker:- You want the company
to actually understand
Speaker:what you spend with them.
Speaker:What, what should they
offer you from a discount?
Speaker:Who is your sales rep?
Speaker:So when you talk
to your sales rep
Speaker:or you talk to the actual company
Speaker:and asking for information,
you want both of those parties
Speaker:to be on the same page.
Speaker:So you as a customer, you want
to know that they know you
Speaker:and show that they know you
through every interaction.
Speaker:- There is a lot of talk at
the moment about the impact
Speaker:of agentic AI, with
some people arguing
Speaker:that it could replace
CRM altogether.
Speaker:Firstly, why are they saying
that? How would it do that?
Speaker:And what is your view about this?
Speaker:- When companies get it right, regardless
Speaker:of the technical architecture, is
Speaker:that the results speak for themselves.
Speaker:Just like the story of L'Oreal.
Speaker:When they shifted 28 brands
Speaker:to purely digital brand during COVID,
Speaker:it fundamentally saved the company.
Speaker:This is information anyone can
go look at and read online.
Speaker:It was a spectacular story
Speaker:of how CRM can really help
innovate into problems
Speaker:of, of opportunity.
Speaker:And, and so I think it's a good story.
Speaker:However, most stories we hear
nowadays are the opposite:
Speaker:legacy workflows, too hard to
modernize to detect that,
Speaker:and expensive license costs.
Speaker:So we see things on social
media all the time about
Speaker:companies that, "I don't need CRM anymore.
Speaker:I can just use agents to build things,
Speaker:and it retires my license costs."
Speaker:And I think that we're going to be running
Speaker:into really interesting,
difficult conversations
Speaker:as those, those archetypes
come to, come to bear.
Speaker:I think that people are conflating
Speaker:"let's replace the CRM interface"
Speaker:with the underlying data
backbone and the capability.
Speaker:What agents in, in our view
are replacing is the screen,
Speaker:the different ways in
which humans are meant
Speaker:to interact with technology.
Speaker:But when you think about
it, agents aren't meant
Speaker:to replace the one
coherent governed
Speaker:compliant record of the customer.
Speaker:In our take, I think there's
four fundamental reasons
Speaker:why you wouldn't replace
a CRM with agents,
Speaker:and we can get to that
one whenever you're ready.
Speaker:- We will get into it, but I do just want
Speaker:to return right back to the start.
Speaker:Is CRM about to become obsolete
Speaker:or more important than ever?
Speaker:What is your take on that?
Speaker:- Is CRM going away?
Speaker:That's a question I, I get
asked on a weekly basis.
Speaker:In short, no. Will it change? Absolutely.
Speaker:I believe and fundamentally
how we engage our,
Speaker:our clients on this topic is
Speaker:it's a nuanced conversation.
Speaker:I was talking to
a CEO of a company.
Speaker:He said, "Why can't I just stitch together
Speaker:multiple bad CRMs with agents
Speaker:and, and go faster?
Speaker:And the answer wasn't you can't.
Speaker:The answer really wasn't
even you shouldn't.
Speaker:The answer was cost,
resources, and innovation.
Speaker:At some point, CFOs, CEOs, CIOs,
Speaker:and the business owners of
the applications actually have
Speaker:to go through a, a thorough discussion
Speaker:and internal investigation to
see what part does CRM play?
Speaker:What, what parts do agents play?
Speaker:Where, how do I work and,
and figure out my data?
Speaker:I always say data is a journey.
Speaker:It's, it's not a destination.
Speaker:And, and where,
who plays which role?
Speaker:And right now, I think that's
Speaker:where a lot of
the discussion is.
Speaker:Why would CRM not go away?
Speaker:So whether you buy
Speaker:a commercial off-the-shelf platform,
Speaker:whether you build it yourself
with your own infrastructure,
Speaker:or whether you leverage
agents in a hyperscaler,
Speaker:CRMs still require
four things and,
Speaker:and support four parts
of the business
Speaker:that will be incredibly
difficult to replace
Speaker:and do so at the speed
and cost that you need.
Speaker:One, your data backbone.
Speaker:Two, scaling your
business processes
Speaker:needed to run your business.
Speaker:Three, verticalization
by industry segment,
Speaker:by regulatory industry,
and by local country law.
Speaker:And number four,
the security posture
Speaker:and investment to secure
your database and your data.
Speaker:Number one is it, it serves
as your data backbone.
Speaker:Organizations have spent
years building up data,
Speaker:good or bad, that allows
them to run their business
Speaker:and support their customers.
Speaker:Number two, it actually
scales business processes.
Speaker:Number three, how
do you industrialize
Speaker:for regulated industries
as well as for countries
Speaker:that have local
data residency laws
Speaker:that require these
platform providers
Speaker:to actually have their,
their customers' data resident
Speaker:in the country,
such as Australia?
Speaker:Those types of regulations as
well as industry-specific ones
Speaker:for financial services,
public sector, healthcare,
Speaker:they require a constant investment
Speaker:and alignment to
changing laws that have
Speaker:to be cascaded down
into the technology
Speaker:within a certain
period of time.
Speaker:Having a partner like
a platform partner
Speaker:that invests in that
with you are advantageous
Speaker:for these CRM companies.
Speaker:And the last one, I think is,
is pretty simple is security.
Speaker:They've invested in
the security posture
Speaker:that agents right now
Speaker:from what we're seeing are
still relatively gapped
Speaker:and don't even make up the full,
Speaker:what I call agentic app
ecosystem that you need to,
Speaker:to build, run, secure,
Speaker:and observe your entire
application landscape.
Speaker:- What about cost?
Speaker:- Cost isn't just the cost of
the agent or the license fee.
Speaker:Cost is also time to value.
How fast can you get it?
Speaker:Agents win a lot when you have
embedded tech debt in CRM.
Speaker:We talked about the problems,
Speaker:but cost also exists when
it comes to the number
Speaker:of resources that are
available in the market
Speaker:that know how to do
things at scale.
Speaker:- Tell me more about that.
Speaker:- The pace of change will never be as slow
Speaker:as it is today, right?
Speaker:That, that is astounding.
Speaker:The Stanford AI Index
of: Speaker:that there are 90,000
agentic AI jobs out there.
Speaker:In our perspective, that was
Speaker:five to seven times lower
than the actual number
Speaker:just for last year alone.
Speaker:And this year, we think that
is actually three times
Speaker:from the actual number
that's required,
Speaker:so not 90,000
times five or seven
Speaker:but 90,000 times eight
to 10 of what's required
Speaker:to support the agentic
job factory
Speaker:that customers are actually needing today.
Speaker:I think the last
one is innovation,
Speaker:which is how fast
can you innovate?
Speaker:And I think this is
where agents have
Speaker:a really cool
opportunity to help.
Speaker:But if you think about it,
cost will continue to be
Speaker:a governing function
for companies
Speaker:because cost is
a lot like a balloon.
Speaker:You can squeeze one side,
Speaker:but the air just moved
to the other, right?
Speaker:There's not infinite amounts
of cost that you can apply
Speaker:to technology and innovation,
Speaker:especially as humans still
want to talk to humans
Speaker:for a majority of the customer life cycle.
Speaker:And as we look at companies
that have spent
Speaker:two to four times the rate
that they expected of agents,
Speaker:that cost is unknown.
Speaker:So we're talking to
CEOs and CFOs saying,
Speaker:"Hey, we can get to the
architecture options,
Speaker:but fundamentally, you
also have to understand
Speaker:what are you going to
spend and where, right?
Speaker:If agents are five times
as expensive as CRM,
Speaker:the math doesn't math anymore."
Speaker:And that's where I think
Speaker:that the really rich
conversation of the nuance
Speaker:between the different models
and options are really going
Speaker:to take place over the
next six, 12, 18 months
Speaker:as the technology
continues to evolve
Speaker:at an incredibly fast pace.
Speaker:- Something that comes up time
and again, whatever industry
Speaker:or whatever guests that I'm
talking to, is this promise
Speaker:of AI helping businesses
to do more for less,
Speaker:but actually that danger of
companies underestimating
Speaker:what it actually costs to
get to where you want to be
Speaker:to use AI at scale.
Speaker:You speak to leaders all
the time in this space.
Speaker:Is there, do you think
that danger is alive
Speaker:in this particular space?
Speaker:- Absolutely. I think CEOs,
Speaker:heads of sales,
CIOs especially
Speaker:are under immense pressure
Speaker:to jump onto the
marketing bandwagon,
Speaker:all really good intentions
Speaker:and targets that have
to be interrogated
Speaker:with, with intent
and I think nuance.
Speaker:And so I think organizations
are looking at this,
Speaker:and they're struggling
with how to get
Speaker:what I call their
wallet put together.
Speaker:How do I actually look at the
expected cost that I know?
Speaker:How do I project out
if I start to unleash?
Speaker:And then what
are the guardrails
Speaker:I have to put in place?
Speaker:And those guardrails aren't
just you can't use it,
Speaker:but it's which model do you use?
Speaker:Which model do you
allow people to use?
Speaker:Here at BCG,
I think we did it.
Speaker:We've been, I think,
pretty thoughtful about it.
Speaker:And it hasn't been perfect,
but it's been thoughtful,
Speaker:which means when we
actually run into a cone,
Speaker:kind of like when you're learning to drive
Speaker:and you run into a cone,
Speaker:you back up, no harm, no foul.
It hasn't been another car.
Speaker:We're intentional who gets what,
Speaker:and we're intentional at
which model they can use.
Speaker:And I think organizations
are going to start
Speaker:to create simulations of cost
that allows them to compare
Speaker:the cost against what they plan for,
Speaker:and then what is the actual
result of the investment
Speaker:against their, their
technology, their CRM.
Speaker:- Bryan, we've spoken a
lot about, understandably,
Speaker:the technology,
but what about people?
Speaker:What does this mean for
people whose jobs are likely
Speaker:to change the most perhaps
over the next few years?
Speaker:- I think when you look
at the use cases that AI
Speaker:and specifically agentic have,
Speaker:the functions they've
been introduced to
Speaker:like marketing, HR, IT are,
Speaker:there's significant implications
Speaker:that organizations have
not thought through, right?
Speaker:And I think that's also gone
into why costs have spiked.
Speaker:Gartner found agentic
models consume
Speaker:five to 30 times more
tokens per task
Speaker:than a standard
chatbot interaction,
Speaker:which means as, as humans
are engaging chats more,
Speaker:and even if the cost of
tokens is going down,
Speaker:the spend is
exponentially going up
Speaker:higher than it is today,
which is alarming.
Speaker:So how did we get there?
You've got customer service.
Speaker:You've got functions that
are required to move faster
Speaker:because the C-suite is saying,
"I need business results."
Speaker:And what we're seeing
is as IT is, is having
Speaker:to build up their competency,
Speaker:the 90,000 jobs not nearly enough,
Speaker:you're seeing business say,
Speaker:"Give it to me.
I will just do it."
Speaker:So I think that's a very big
discussion on who owns what
Speaker:when it comes to not only the agents,
Speaker:but defining the workflows,
defining the experience,
Speaker:defining the future-state process.
Speaker:But then the middle
ground, which is, right,
Speaker:so if I just go here and
then you've got IT coming in
Speaker:from this side to pick
things up and run it through,
Speaker:is I think you're going to
start to see a redefinition
Speaker:of who owns further down
Speaker:the software development life cycle,
Speaker:the product development
life cycle, meaning
Speaker:can it be a business person
who orchestrates the agent
Speaker:to do the basic config, configuration,
Speaker:to do the functional design
Speaker:that typically sits within
the technology teams?
Speaker:And if so, what happens
to the technology teams,
Speaker:and who does,
who does which part?
Speaker:So I think that is a huge
part of the discussion
Speaker:when it comes to who does
what in the future of,
Speaker:of this hybrid model of CRM plus agentic.
Speaker:- What happens if
you don't prioritize
Speaker:those conversations now?
Speaker:Why is it so important?
Shake it all out for me.
Speaker:What's going to happen
in five, 10 years' time
Speaker:if you haven't had
these conversations now?
Speaker:- Oh, just five to 10 years?
Can I, can I take it ...
Speaker:- Well, three, two, whatever.
Speaker:- Can I take it in six to 12
months because I think it.
Speaker:So I think three is fine.
Speaker:Three is, three is actually good.
Speaker:Anything beyond three years
and we're really scientific
Speaker:and sci-fi movies at that point.
Speaker:- Yeah.
Speaker:- So, well, I think
there's a few concepts
Speaker:that I think we'll run towards,
Speaker:though the final destination
is still relatively fuzzy.
Speaker:I think, one, CRMs and
platforms will continue
Speaker:to move towards headless.
Speaker:I think it's going to be
a table stakes for them
Speaker:as they change their
commercial models,
Speaker:that they harness the data
backbone as their secret sauce
Speaker:and help organizations
really take advantage
Speaker:of the agentic moment.
Speaker:I think, number two,
we're going to see agents
Speaker:really take the place of bolt-ons
Speaker:that have existed today to
where CRMs have been gapped.
Speaker:These agents are going
Speaker:to help organizations
innovate at scale
Speaker:for those, those use cases.
Speaker:I think it's also going to
be the experience layer,
Speaker:and it's going to
help connect data
Speaker:across different channels
Speaker:and different,
different customers.
Speaker:And I think that's very different
Speaker:from how we see it today,
Speaker:where CRMs are monolithic
applications
Speaker:that really drive,
Speaker:I call it distrust and lack of lovability
Speaker:to where agents get to
help actually massage it
Speaker:back to value to
back to the company.
Speaker:And that's the three-year
view for me is
Speaker:that at that point,
we can come back
Speaker:and say, "Bryan, are CRMs
going to exist again?"
Speaker:Let's have take two.
I don't know.
Speaker:- Yeah. Yes, indeed.
There you go.
Speaker:Bryan, we've covered the so what.
Speaker:What about the now what?
Speaker:If you're a CEO listening to this,
Speaker:what are your next immediate steps?
Speaker:- Don't start with the
build versus buy decision.
Speaker:Start by getting your chief
sales and revenue officer,
Speaker:your head of customer support,
Speaker:your head of digital
and legal and tech
Speaker:and finance in a room.
Speaker:And it's not about
let's agree
Speaker:on the first place
we're going to go build,
Speaker:but align on the principles
Speaker:in which you're going to
govern your investments.
Speaker:What should an agent do,
Speaker:or what, what should an
agent do that CRM can't?
Speaker:What is the implication
of who can deliver that
Speaker:in the cost profile for them,
Speaker:both the human cost as
well as the agentic cost?
Speaker:What does that do when it comes
Speaker:to longer-term scaled value
Speaker:since the moment you go through
Speaker:the let's let a thousand
flowers bloom,
Speaker:you're unable to
actually understand
Speaker:which flower, why did it bloom,
Speaker:and what's going to
really nurture it
Speaker:to grow in the way you need it?
Speaker:So you understand cost,
resource, and innovation.
Speaker:So if you go over your
spend, it's done.
Speaker:If you don't have enough
resources in the room,
Speaker:then who do you go to?
Speaker:If innovation isn't
fast enough based
Speaker:on what a functional leader
needs, then pause, right?
Speaker:That's going to help people
get to a proof point.
Speaker:- Bryan, what role will
consultants play in all this?
Speaker:- Oh, a self-serving answer
I could give, but I shall not.
Speaker:I do fundamentally believe
Speaker:that the expertise is not
going to be in the agents.
Speaker:I think they're going to be commoditized.
Speaker:And so if we think about
the role of consulting firms
Speaker:and who's in the room when
you start to innovate, is
Speaker:that the people that understand
Speaker:the business context,
the strategy can design
Speaker:the future-state processes going
Speaker:from 10 sales stages
down to six.
Speaker:Why do you need five sales
motions versus 14, right?
Speaker:What's the forecasting method
Speaker:for each of those,
and how do you go?
Speaker:That's a business discussion that's based
Speaker:on strategy and data
and best practices,
Speaker:not based on how you
configured a tool.
Speaker:And so I fundamentally think
consulting is going to go back
Speaker:to, dare I say it, actually
consulting organizations
Speaker:on what they should and
should not be doing,
Speaker:how they should be doing it,
Speaker:and the agents are going
to be doing the work.
Speaker:For services providers,
professional services firm,
Speaker:I think what we're going
to see is we're going
Speaker:to see a shrink and a
shift for those consultants
Speaker:who provide services for the
customers of salesforce.com,
Speaker:Dynamics, the other CRM providers.
Speaker:When we look at that shift,
Speaker:I think we talk about
it from a who is going
Speaker:to be the orchestrator
of the agents, right?
Speaker:Think about it
differently in this way.
Speaker:Today, the constraining factor
Speaker:of most transformations
are business decisions
Speaker:and the change of how you
do things today to tomorrow
Speaker:and the technology
and technology teams
Speaker:that are responsible
for delivering that
Speaker:in order to drive process
scale and automation.
Speaker:Today, that technology team is constrained
Speaker:by capacity and, and time.
Speaker:What agents do is it makes the development
Speaker:and the repeatability
Speaker:of quality development
a commodity,
Speaker:which means while you need
high-end tech capacity
Speaker:and skills, actual doing of
the build should be pushed
Speaker:more and more towards agents.
Speaker:Now, do I think it's going to be immediate
Speaker:where you're pushing the entirety
Speaker:of your software development
life cycle to agents?
Speaker:No. In fact, you're going
to have throttle limits
Speaker:on how much can go
into these platforms
Speaker:and drive, you know,
automated builds,
Speaker:and you're going to want to
have, you know, quality checks
Speaker:to make sure you're
doing it right.
Speaker:But the momentum and the swing
Speaker:and the shift is
already underway.
Speaker:So the real dialogue, the real discussion
Speaker:within both professional services
Speaker:and within the company's
organizations
Speaker:that run these are who
orchestrates the agents
Speaker:and what's the special
sauce that goes into
Speaker:what the agents should do?
Speaker:And so I actually believe
that the companies,
Speaker:and services firms specifically,
Speaker:they're going to win
are going to be the ones
Speaker:that can harness
their internal context
Speaker:and knowledge, kind
of that big brain,
Speaker:and then bring that into the
agents for a client specific
Speaker:and then deploy that to help
them actually accelerate.
Speaker:So I believe the, the change
fundamentally is going to be
Speaker:how do you upskill your
clients in agentic build,
Speaker:so they can take
it on themselves
Speaker:versus having long-tail run
support that's outsourced.
Speaker:I think it's how do you
accelerate transformation
Speaker:from the business side and
the decisions you're making,
Speaker:which I believe is
a sweet spot for BCG
Speaker:as a business integrator.
Speaker:And then, I believe, how
do you actually contract
Speaker:towards outcomes, which I
think will be a tectonic shift
Speaker:on how do you actually move into,
Speaker:I will sign up for an outcome
Speaker:that allows you to turn on
this new process, the entirety
Speaker:of the platform
within three to six months
Speaker:and do it at scale versus
12 to 18 to 24 months.
Speaker:It's going to be table
stakes to get it right.
Speaker:- Bryan, thank you so much,
and thank you for listening.
Speaker:If you'd like to find out
more about the subject,
Speaker:you can find links to
BCG's research in this area
Speaker:in the show notes.